Wednesday, April 25, 2007

* does evil exist? *

One day, a professor of a university decided to defy
his pupils. He asked: "Did God create everything
that exists?"

A student answered bravely:
"yes, He did."
"Everything?," asked the teacher.
"Yes, everything," was the answer of the student
.


"In this case, God also created evil, correct?

Because evil exists," said the teacher.
To that, the student had no answer and remained in

silence. The teacher was delighted at the opportunity
to prove one more time that faith was only a myth.

Suddenly, another student raised his hand and asked:

"May I ask you a question, professor?"
"Of course,"
was the answer.
"Does cold exist?"
"Of course,"
answered the professor.

"Did you never feel cold?"

"Actually, sir, cold does not exist.

According to studies in Physics, cold is the total
and complete absence of heat. An object can only
be studied if it has and transmits energy and it is
the heat of an object that transmits its energy.
Without heat, the objects are inert, incapable to
react. But cold does not exist. We created the

term 'cold' to explain the lack of heat."

"And darkness?" continues the student.
"It exists," replied the professor.

"Again, you're wrong, sir. Darkness is the total

absence of light. You can study light and brightness,
but not darkness. The prism of Nichols shows the
variety of different colors in which the light can
be decomposed according to the longitude of the
waves. Darkness is the term we created to explain

the total absence of light."

And finally, the student asked:
"And evil, sir, does evil exist?"
"God did not create evil. Evil is the absence of

God in people's hearts. It is the absence of love,
humanity and faith. Love and faith are like heat

and light. They exist. Their absence lead to evil."

Now it was the professor's turn to remain silent.

The name of the student was:
ALBERT EINSTEIN

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Cold and Heat is a natural element. Light and Darkness is also a natural element. The absence of one will lead to the other.

Good and Evil is not a natural element. The absence of one does not necessarily lead to the other. For example if you see people in need and you did not do good. Does that means you are evil?

On the other hand. If a person had to kill another to prevent the latter killing thousands of people, does that equates the former to be evil (for killing someone)?

If you agree with the killing of potential murderer then you agrees that good was done by an act which is by itself evil. So what is "good"? The absence of good is the cause of evil? Or, in this case, the presence of evil vindicates the good?

* c.h.s. * said...

In certain extend, I would agree with you that God and Evil are not natural elements thus the absence of one doesn't necessarily lead to the other.

Example, if a 6-year old boy was mocked by his classmates, he would instantly mocking back or even start fighting. But if we are mocked by our colleagues, would we be consciously start a fight?

Eventhough now we refer and discuss a story told by someone we don't even know, I would like to quote its closing paragraph, ie. "God did not create evil. Evil is the absence of God in people's hearts. It is the absence of love,
humanity and faith. Love and faith are like heat and light. They exist. Their absence lead to evil."

Accordingly, I would think that naturally, grown-ups are comport with dignity and restraint. In such a way we are able to qualified ourselves as people who has love, humanity and faith. I believe there're still so many characters out there to qualify a good person. Being a good person will bring us to the stage where we can say that in the presence of God, Evil won't exist.

Eventually, all good behaviours in our heart will ameliorate us to deal with every circumstances.